Affordable Rates for Toyota Corolla Insurance in Cincinnati

  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Cincinnati Auto Insurance
  4. >
  5. Toyota Corolla

Feel like you have an overpriced car insurance policy? Believe me, you're not alone.

Insurance quote for Toyota Corolla in CincinnatiIt's an obvious conclusion that car insurance companies want to keep you from comparing prices. Drivers who get price quotes annually will probably switch to a new company because there are good odds of finding good coverage at a lower price. Surprisingly, a recent survey revealed that consumers who shopped around annually saved approximately $865 annually compared to other drivers who don't regularly compare prices.

If finding the cheapest price for insurance in Cincinnati is your ultimate objective, then having a good understanding how to get price quotes and compare insurance coverage can help you be more efficient.

There are many auto insurance companies to purchase coverage from, and though it is a good thing to have a selection, too many choices makes it more difficult to compare rates for Toyota Corolla insurance in Cincinnati.

Consumers need to compare prices as often as possible because insurance rates fluctuate regularly. Just because you found the lowest rate on Toyota Corolla insurance in Cincinnati six months ago a different company probably has better prices today. Ignore everything you know about car insurance because you're about to find out how to quote online to eliminate unnecessary coverages and save money on Toyota Corolla insurance in Cincinnati.

Companies offering cheap Toyota Corolla rates in Cincinnati, OH

The car insurance companies shown below have been selected to offer free quotes in Ohio. If you want cheaper auto insurance in Cincinnati, it's a good idea that you visit as many as you can to get the most competitive price.

Insurance coverage analysis

The rate information displayed next showcases a range of rate quotes for Toyota Corolla models. Having a better understanding of how insurance policy premiums are figured can be of help when making informed purchases.

Toyota Corolla Insurance Rates in Cincinnati, OH
Model Comp Collision Liability Medical UM/UIM Annual Premium Monthly Premium
Corolla LE $162 $280 $298 $18 $88 $846 $71
Corolla S $162 $280 $298 $18 $88 $846 $71
Corolla XLE $162 $280 $298 $18 $88 $846 $71
Corolla XRS $184 $280 $298 $18 $88 $868 $72
Get Your Own Custom Quote Go

Prices based on single male driver age 30, no speeding tickets, no at-fault accidents, $500 deductibles, and Ohio minimum liability limits. Discounts applied include multi-vehicle, safe-driver, homeowner, multi-policy, and claim-free. Rate information does not factor in specific garaging location which can impact rates greatly.

Policy deductible comparison

The hardest decision when buying coverage is what deductibles to buy. The following insurance rates may aid in understanding the premium difference when you select higher and lower coverage deductibles. The first pricing table uses a $100 deductible for comprehensive and collision coverage and the second data table uses a $500 deductible.

Toyota Corolla insurance rates with $100 deductibles
Model Comp Collision Liability Medical UM/UIM Annual Premium Monthly Premium
Corolla LE $196 $416 $226 $14 $68 $945 $79
Corolla S $196 $416 $226 $14 $68 $945 $79
Corolla XLE $196 $416 $226 $14 $68 $945 $79
Corolla XRS $220 $416 $226 $14 $68 $969 $81
Get Your Own Custom Quote Go
Toyota Corolla insurance rates with $500 deductibles
Model Comp Collision Liability Medical UM/UIM Annual Premium Monthly Premium
Corolla LE $142 $280 $226 $14 $68 $730 $61
Corolla S $142 $280 $226 $14 $68 $730 $61
Corolla XLE $142 $280 $226 $14 $68 $730 $61
Corolla XRS $160 $280 $226 $14 $68 $748 $62
Get Your Own Custom Quote Go

Data variables include married male driver age 30, no speeding tickets, no at-fault accidents, and Ohio minimum liability limits. Discounts applied include multi-policy, multi-vehicle, claim-free, homeowner, and safe-driver. Table data does not factor in vehicle location which can influence price quotes substantially.

Based on the above data, using a $100 deductible will cost you approximately $19 more each month or $228 each year than requesting the higher $500 deductible. Since you would pay $400 more to settle a claim with a $500 deductible as compared to a $100 deductible, if you tend to have at a minimum 21 months between claims, you would probably come out ahead if you elect the higher deductible.

Lower rate quotes by taking advantage of discounts

Car insurance is easily one of your largest bills, but there may be some discounts to help offset the cost. Certain discounts will be applied when you purchase, but once in a while a discount must be asked about in order for you to get them.

  • Pay Early and Save - If you pay your bill all at once as opposed to paying monthly you could save up to 5%.
  • Telematics Discount - Drivers that enable data collection to analyze driving manner through the use of a telematics system such as In-Drive from State Farm or Allstate's Drivewise system could possibly reduce rates if they exhibit good driving behavior.
  • Discounts for New Vehicles - Buying insurance coverage on a new vehicle may earn a small discount since newer vehicles are generally safer.
  • Multi-car Discount - Insuring primary and secondary vehicles on the same car insurance policy can reduce rates for all insured vehicles.
  • Service Members Pay Less - Being on active duty in the military may lower your rates slightly.
  • Waiver for an Accident - This one isn't a discount, but some insurance companies will forgive one accident before hitting you with a surcharge if you have no claims for a set time period.
  • Professional Organizations - Affiliation with specific professional or occupational memberships or organizations is a simple method to lower premiums on car insurance.
  • Early Signing - Some car insurance companies give discounts for switching to them prior to your current Corolla insurance policy expiration. You may see this discount when you get Cincinnati auto insurance quotes online.
  • Passive Restraint Discount - Vehicles equipped with air bags can get savings of up to 25% or more.
  • Good Driver Discount - Drivers who don't get into accidents could pay up to 40% less than drivers with accident claims.

Consumers should know that most of the big mark downs will not be given to the entire cost. Most only cut specific coverage prices like physical damage coverage or medical payments. So even though it sounds like you can get free auto insurance, you're out of luck.

The diagram below compares Toyota Corolla auto insurance costs with and without discounts applied to the premium. The costs are based on a male driver, no violations or accidents, Ohio state minimum liability limits, full physical damage coverage, and $100 deductibles. The first bar for each age group shows premium with no discounts. The second shows the rates with homeowner, safe-driver, multi-policy, multi-car, marriage, and claim-free discounts applied.

Insurance companies that may offer most of these discounts may include but are not limited to:

It's a good idea to ask every insurance company which credits you are entitled to. Some discounts may not apply in Cincinnati. If you would like to see a list of providers that offer multiple discounts in Ohio, follow this link.

Will just any policy work for me?

When it comes to choosing coverage online or from an agent, there really is no one size fits all plan. Coverage needs to be tailored to your specific needs and a cookie cutter policy won't apply. For example, these questions may help highlight if your situation might need professional guidance.

  • When should I have rental car coverage?
  • Do I have coverage when pulling a U-Haul trailer?
  • Can my babysitter drive my car?
  • What exactly is covered by my policy?
  • If I use my vehicle for business use is it covered?
  • Does coverage extend to Mexico or Canada?

If you can't answer these questions but a few of them apply then you might want to talk to a licensed insurance agent. To find lower rates from a local agent, complete this form or you can go here for a list of companies in your area.

You may want advice from an agent

Certain consumers just prefer to get advice from a local agent and that is OK! One of the benefits of getting online price quotes is you can get cheap auto insurance quotes and still have a local agent.

Insurance agents in CincinnatiTo help locate an agent, after submitting this quick form, your information is transmitted to agents in your area that give free quotes for your auto insurance coverage. It's much easier because you don't need to contact any insurance agencies as quotes are delivered to your email. You can get cheaper auto insurance rates and a licensed agent to talk to. If for some reason you want to get a price quote from a specific company, you would need to search and find their rate quote page and submit a quote form there.

Deciding on an company requires you to look at more than just a cheap price quote. These are valid questions to ask:

  • Will you work with the agent or an assistant?
  • Is the quote a firm price?
  • Are claims handled at the agent's location?
  • What are their preferred companies if they are an independent agency?
  • How many companies do they write for?
  • Is the agent properly licensed in Ohio?
  • What company holds the largest book of business for them?
  • Can glass repairs be made at your home?

Exclusive agents vs. Independent agents

If you want a good insurance agency, there are two types of agencies and how they can quote your rates. Insurance agencies in Cincinnati can be categorized as either independent agents or exclusive agents depending on their employer.

Exclusive Agencies

Agents that elect to be exclusive can only provide one company's prices and some examples include Farmers Insurance or State Farm. Exclusive agents are unable to provide rate quotes from other companies so always compare other rates. Exclusive agencies are usually quite knowledgeable on the products they sell and that can be a competitive advantage.

Listed below is a short list of exclusive agencies in Cincinnati who can help you get price quote information.


5062 Delhi Ave - Cincinnati, OH 45238 - (513) 451-8700 - View Map


882 Ohio Pike - Cincinnati, OH 45245 - (513) 752-2144 - View Map


3518 Glenmore Ave - Cincinnati, OH 45211 - (513) 662-4300 - View Map

View more agents

Independent Insurance Agents

Independent agents do not write with just one company so they can quote policies through lots of different companies and find you the best rates. To move your coverage to a new company, an independent agent can move your coverage which requires no work on your part. When comparison shopping, it's a good idea to get several quotes from at least one independent agent to ensure the widest selection of prices.

Listed below are Cincinnati independent agents willing to provide price quote information.


4355 Ferguson Dr #155 - Cincinnati, OH 45245 - (513) 947-8500 - View Map


3356 N Bend Rd - Cincinnati, OH 45239 - (513) 389-4100 - View Map


2756 Erie Ave - Cincinnati, OH 45208 - (513) 321-2000 - View Map

View more agents

Ohio car insurance company ratings

Ending up with the highest-rated auto insurance provider is hard considering how many companies sell coverage in Cincinnati. The ranking information shown below may help you pick which car insurance companies to look at comparing rates from.

Top 10 Cincinnati Car Insurance Companies Ranked by Value

  1. USAA
  2. GEICO
  3. AAA Insurance
  4. Erie Insurance
  5. State Farm
  6. Liberty Mutual
  7. Safeco Insurance
  8. Allstate
  9. 21st Century
  10. Travelers

Don't give up on affordable rates

Budget-conscious Toyota Corolla insurance can be found online as well as from insurance agents, so you should compare both to have the best selection. Some insurance providers may not have price quotes online and most of the time these regional insurance providers prefer to sell through independent insurance agencies.

As you quote Cincinnati auto insurance, do not reduce coverage to reduce premium. In too many instances, drivers have reduced comprehensive coverage or liability limits to discover at claim time that the savings was not a smart move. Your aim should be to purchase a proper amount of coverage at the best cost while still protecting your assets.

How to find cheaper Toyota Corolla insurance in Cincinnati

The easiest way to find cheaper prices for auto insurance rates is to begin comparing prices regularly from insurers that insure vehicles in Cincinnati. Drivers can shop around by following these guidelines.

  1. Learn about coverages and the things you can control to drop your rates. Many policy risk factors that increase rates such as traffic citations, accidents, and a negative credit history can be eliminated by making minor changes in your lifestyle.
  2. Request rate estimates from exclusive agents, independent agents, and direct providers. Exclusive agents and direct companies can only quote rates from one company like GEICO or State Farm, while independent agents can provide prices from multiple insurance companies.
  3. Compare the quotes to your current policy premium to see if a cheaper price is available. If you can save some money and buy the policy, make sure coverage is continuous and does not lapse.

The most important part of shopping around is that you'll want to make sure you compare similar deductibles and liability limits on each quote and and to get rate quotes from as many carriers as you can. This ensures an accurate price comparison and a complete rate analysis.

Even more information is available at these sites: